Nov 28, 2006
Hilary Duff and Joel Madden Break Up
Teenybopper starlet Hilary Duff is said to have called it quits with long-time boyfriend Joel Madden. The Chicago Tribune reports:
Madden made a guest DJ appearance at Enclave on Wednesday night and openly talked about how he is currently single. Madden told clubgoers Duff broke up with him about ten days ago and that their eight-year age difference was causing problems. (Madden is 27, Duff is 19.)
Hilary probably broke up with Joel because he stopped giving her sugar cubes and carrots and got lazy about brushing her tail every day. Horses need lots of love and attention. Especially horses with eating disorders. Some people just don’t have any business owning pets.
41 Comments, Comment or Ping
Zanna
She’s like a fat girl that loses weight and then dumps her boyfriend. Except she’s not fat. She just had her teeth filed down.
Nov 28th, 2006
Walrus Gumboot
But they were so made for each other.
Nov 28th, 2006
Krizzatch
Big age differences never work in relationships. Take it from me, I was 7 and my uncle was 48. Wasn’t like Uncle Ralph didn’t try though.
Nov 28th, 2006
abby
You know what else doesn’t work? Besides an age difference, I mean? A “species difference.” Me and that goat with the big wiener just couldn’t work it out. The sex was great, though. Some things just aren’t mean to be.
Nov 28th, 2006
Nicole
im sad. but happy. joel loved her. he was happy with her. but i hated her anyway. i hate to see him hurt
Nov 30th, 2006
Noor
Yeah. I’m not a big fan of her so it doesnt matter. He’s not all hurt about it ne ways.. he is Joel Madden, he could get ne girl he wants.
Plus.. she goes out with him for 2 1/2 years.. and AFTER all of that she is gonna be like “ohh.. ur too old” thats total BullSH*T and im sure there was another reason but w.e
joel we have a 12 year age difference and i would marry you.(lol)
age is just a number if you honestly love the person, so she obviously didnt love him back. so there is no point.
Nov 30th, 2006
Patt
Oh my God!! I don’t see what Hilary did to any of you to be so harsh to her. I was surprise when their relationship started, in a good way, I mean. I’ve been a fan od Good Cahrlotte from the beginning and I always thought Joel would end up with a girl like that. A regular girl! He always said in every single enterview that he like girls like that better than punked up girls. I’m very sad they broke up. I thought they were perfect together. And ever since they started dating I grew in love with her like I didn’t think was possible. She is great and he is great and I sincerely hope they find their way back to each other.
Dec 7th, 2006
KIMBERELY
I think Hilary Duff is so STUPIDE for braking up with him only because of their age I THINK THAT IS A REALLY STUPIDE RESON
Dec 15th, 2006
RealDeal
u know wat.. hilary did a good thing breaking up with joEl. She is wayyyyy too good for him and he’s just a self centered jerk. If he didnt care enough about her worries then its a good thing they are not together anymore coz she would just be wasting her time on him. and anyway.. he’s all emo pffft thats so sad. y doesnt he go just sing a fkN depressin s0ng whilE cutting himself? hahaha maybe dat will cheer him up. p.s GC SUCKS!!!!
Dec 16th, 2006
Ashley
“RealDeal” your a fucking idiot. Just cause Joel writes meaningful lyrics, does not mean he cuts himself and all that shit. It just means he has a deep side. Jesus. And, Joel is far from a jerk. Personally I think Hilary was a bitch who had him whipped, so its good they broke up. She probably treated him like a dog. And besides, she looks like a horse. And trust me, Joel wont be all depressed about losing some horse bitch. Apperentally hes with Nicole Richie now, so yeah, guess hes over Hilary and not all depressed. And Good Charlotte does not suck, if anything, Hilary Duff sucks. She actually has no singing talent. Or writing talent. Joel and Good Charlotte has had to write her last couple songs, cause she has no talent to do so. And, cause horses cant write songs anyways.
So yeah, RealDeal, just up now
Dec 19th, 2006
anna
Oh, in my opinion, they were a perfect couple! I’m sad. :*( I can’t understand why Hil wanted to broke up; Joel is such a great guy, i think. Hil is cute too..and maybe she had a some trouble with their ages, but still..
Age difference isn’t good reason to broke up, is it? Nowadays all hollywood couples broke up, i see. hope they’ll come back together! (I’m sorry if that text includes lots of flaws ’cause I’m finn and i can’t write english that good ;D)
Dec 27th, 2006
Kayla
Well personally I think that they were a great couple and should have sta7yed together! No, she dosn’t have an eating disorder, maybe you are just jelouse because she is a lot better than you and she had a really hot boyfriend!
Hilary duff, if you ever read this I sure do hope that you can visit Edmonton Alberta one day soon.
LOvE,
Kayla Whitford 13
Dec 27th, 2006
hale
Ever since Hilary started going out with Joel, it’s like she started to change herself. I only found her pretty during the Lizzie McGuire series. I’m kinda glad they broke up now because maybe Hilary can go back to her real self instead of a wannabe punker. Hmm…her next relationship would be…that one guy Ethan from her Lizzie McGuire series…lol.
Dec 28th, 2006
lorein
god hilary broke up with joel but its not a big deal for those of u who think hes hearts broken get your facts straight he was the one who was seen getting cosy with nicole richie 2 weeks later.
Jan 12th, 2007
amelie
I’m shocked Hilary and Joel broke up they had such a long relationship and hilary took that long to figure out the big age difference.I used to be a huge fan and I even went to her concert then I relized shes one hell of a bad dancer and is in it for the money I hpoe hilary gets back to normal rather than the girl who curses with her boyfriend and sister.I wish she would dye her hair blonde again she looks bad now.Maybe I would love her like I used to.
Jan 17th, 2007
HILARY HATE'R
HILARY DUFF IS A STUPID ANO THAT DOESN’T HAVE A LIFE SHES GAY AND JOEL DESERVES AND CAN DO BETTER THAN THAT THING!
Jan 18th, 2007
hilary fan
omggg i thought they would get married with eachother omgggg i am sooo pisssed i hate nicole richieeeeee whyed she have to come in the picture. it sux!!! i wish they get back with eachother. there was no freaken reason for them to break up!!! they were such a good couple. i loved them i thought they would get married. but now they won’t they areeee aparttttt ahhhhhh it killed me reading about how they broke up!!! omg i think they should get back with eachother and not have nicole richie in the picture!!! ahhhh i hate nicole richie!!!!!! whyd they have to break up ahhhhh oh man
Jan 19th, 2007
SO....?
I think that people should mind their own bussiness. Relatioships do not work out sometimes, and you have to just move on; it is better than pretending that every thing is okay, when deep down, it is not. Maybe it is the best for the both of them; A New Begining.
Jan 24th, 2007
joel fan1312
relationships are delicate things.sometimes they work sometimes they dont.if joel goes for nicole richie then he does!w.e.!!!!!!!!hilary was trying to be something she wasnt.maybe it was for the best?personally…i think they were soo cute together but looks arent wat counts!right??and besides no one knows what was really going on when the photographers werent around.hes way too machure for her anyway.hes nice but he was too old for her.thats why she was trying to change to look more mature.for him!i love joel !!!!!!!!!!lol.sooo yah its there business not mine!or anywone elses for that matter!
p.s. GOOD CHARLOTTE ROX! joel if u ever read this me and my brothers love you guys!we hope to see u in the future at a concert!xoxoxo
Jan 26th, 2007
joel fan1312
if joel goes for nicole richie then he goes for her!w.e.relationships are delicate things.sometimes they work sometimes they dont!oh well…move on!i love joel!lol…hilary was trying to change for him cuz he was to old.i thought they were cute together!oh well.no one really knows what was going on when the photographers werent around!not my busines or anyone elses!
p.s.GOOD CHARLOTTE ROX!joel if u ever read this me and my brothers love you guys!and we hope to see u at a concert in the future!good luck with nicole or any other girl in the future!xoxo….email me at daisyduke11_11@hotmail.com luv u joel!
Jan 26th, 2007
Gabriella
they wre so match 4 each other fk nicole n goback with hilary again
Jan 29th, 2007
Linda
i thought that joel and hilary made such a cute couple. for all you people who thought joel can do so much better than hilary well he cant b cuz he is dating nicole now so what do you think about that and hilary was so much better than nicole. he went from a pretty talented girl to a ugly untalented bitch nicole is so stupid she cant even do anything for her self she cant sing act she cant do shit she just has her fame from her dad and hilary made herself famous she actually has talent so i hope that joel and hilary can make things better between themselves and get back together b cuz they both belong together joel does not belong with that ugly ass bitch nicole who looks like she is about to die b cuz she is so fucking skinny does not even have meat on her bones make things better joel and hilary
you guyz both rock……and nicole you suck………..
Feb 2nd, 2007
MoRgAn
i think that hilary duff and joel madden’s split IS NOT A E SHOCKER TO ME. ok. i knew that they werent goin be together forever. like common on people. ok. ITS HOLLYWOOD. people get together for like two months. or w/e. then after that its OVER. ok. nicole richie and joel madden’s relationship is soo FAKE its disguisting. OK. B/C was watchin an episode of the simple life. and this guy wanted his dughter to look like hilary duff for her school pictures. and nicole richie the bitch that she is commented him back saying, “the teen hilary, or the one that just got out of bed with joel madden”…like wtf..she made fun of them and no alll of a sudden she LOVES JOEL..fuck outta here. pleaase. this thing that they call a “relationship” aint gonna last..sorry..but it aint. and i dunt support pple like her. like i love joel madden. i think hes a hotti and i aint the only gurl who thinks that. but listennnn TO ALL THE GURLS THAT ARE IN A RELATIONSHIP OR PLAN ON BEING IN ONE SOON…..when u love sumeone..u are supposed to ALWAYS be there 4 them, and ALWAYS take care of them, AND ALWAYS ALWAYS encourage them…OK..joel dunt love nicole richie…i can tell u that mucHHH….if he really loved her h would tell her to put more fucking weight onn..cuz she still a friggen toothpicK. and if he encouraged her I WOULD BE SEEING HER IN MORE MOVIES. AND HAVING A LIFEE..like wat does she do thats soooo COOL. NOTHING. ok. ALL OF U GUYS WANNA MAKE FUN OF HILARY..HILARY HAS A LIFEE.OK. JUST B/C U DUNT LIKE HER MUSIC. OR ACTING. OR W/E OK AT LEASTE SHE DOES SUMETHING. COMPARED TO NICOLE RICHIE. OK. WAT DOES THAT FUCKING UGLY,ANOREXIC, SLUT, TWO-FACED, BUM DO????? NOTHING. OK…SOO STOP DISING HILARY..OK. AT LEAST SHE AINT A SLUT. OK. AT LEAST SHE DOES SUMETHING USFUL WITH HER LIFEEE… OK. SHE DOES WAT SHE LOVES. AND THATS SINGING AND ACTING. OK. SAY WAT U WANT. BUT NICOLE RICHIE HAS NO REASON BEING IN MAGAZINES AT ALL. OK. NO REASON. HILARY DUFF MADE HERSELF. OK. AND I LUVED HILARY AND JOEL TOGETHER. AND AGE DOESNT MATTER. OK. THEY WERE OLY 8 YEARS APART. THAT AINT BAD AT ALL. LYKE WTF. LOOK AT ASHTON KUTCHER AND DEMI MOORE. LIKE I LOVE THEM 2 TOGETHER. OK. AND THEY ARE LASTING LONG THEN ANY FUCKIN HOLLYWOOD COUPLE. LIKE SERIOUSLY. AGE DUNT MATTER. WAT MATTERS IS IF U LOVE THE PERSON. CUZ IF U SAY AGE MATTERS UR SAYING COLOR OF SKIN MATTERS, HEIGHT MATTERS, EYE COLOR MATTER, NATIONALITY MATTERS, SEX MATTERS. OK.. NOOO UR WRONG……THAT DUNT MATTERR..LOVE ISNT ABOUT BEING THE SAME AT ALLL…OK. WEN I LOOKED LOVE UP IN THE DICTONARY IT NEVER SAID ” IN ORDER TO BE IN LOVE U HAVE TO BE THE SAME COLOR, NATIONALITY, AGE, HEIGHT. IT NEVER EVER SAID THAT……IM A WHITE, 15, ITALAIN, GURL. oK. I WOULD DATE SUMEONE COMPLETELY OPPOSITE OF MEE…CUZ THE OPPOSITES ARE THE ONES THAT ATTRACT. SOOOOO……. YEAH!!!!!!! I WOULDNT CARE IF THE GUY I DATED WAS BLACK, OR HAWIANN, OR PURTA-RICIAN, OR SPAINASH, OR LATINO, OR W/E. IT DOESNT MATTER. ESPECIALLY AGE….OK. WELL IT SORTA DOES WEN UR LIKE A MINOR. CUZ IF UR A MINOR U CANT HAVE SEX WITH SUMEONE WHO IS OVER 18. ITS AGIANST THE LAW. PEOPLE CONSIDERED THAT SATATORY RAPE. BUT ANWAYS BEING SMART AS HILARY IS SHE DIDNT HAVE SEX WITH JOEL. AND THATS ONE MAJOR REASON I THINK THEY BBROKE UP…HE WANTED TO HAVE SEX AND SHE SAID NO. NO MIND U IF IT WAS ME I SAY HELLL YESS TO JOEL IN A HEART BEAT. BUT THN AGAIN HILARY IS SMART AND MADE A WISE DESICION IN SAYING NO. and i know thats why. its soo obvious too. i love joel. but hilary didnt want it. i believe thats how it all went down/ so joel picked up the sluttiest, whoriest gurl he could find. and hes only using NIOLCE RICHIE. sorry to say. but he is. like he broke up with hilary 10 days b4 he hooked up with nicole. sorryyy..hes just using niolce richie tooo get over his feelings from hilary. SORRY THIS IS SOO FRIGGEN LONG BUT SOMEONE HAD TO REALIZE WAT I WAS SAYING. I MISS U JOEL AND HIL!!!!! THAT WAAS REALLLL LOVE.
Feb 8th, 2007
Maira
Guys. If you have been bf and gf for 1 or 2 years and you guys had the age diffrence then. But why do you have too worry now! You guys are the 2 best parteners in Little ANGEL mag I think!!
I don’t think its any of Hil1arys fault! And i think its stupid that people bring about how they look in a love matter! So Riduculous!
Go Hillary!
Feb 19th, 2007
lisa
well i dunt relly care i not a real hilary fan and im not a joel madden fan either but its not a shocker i mean shes like 19 and im 19 (im a coupla months older than her) i shud know it wuznt gonnawork out in the first place so no surprise but im still questioning about the fact that she is a virgin..is she or is she not cuz the vid for with love just tells me she had sex and the fact that she wud give herself up to a stakler. well i respected her bfore but now ive lost all that respect beacuse in her vid it looks like shes a whore i mean shes becoming more and more like those hollywood pricks aka paris hilton and all those other sluts. i like the song but i see no dignity for us women in that video.
Mar 2nd, 2007
Humayraa sidat
i think it is good hilary duff had broke up with him because i hate that joel madden
Apr 9th, 2007
Jessica
There was also speculation that he dumped her because she wouldn’t have sex with him.
Apr 10th, 2007
sarah
I freel bad 4 her wean i heard hilary broke up wit joel and joel has the nerve to look her a girl and get married to nichol. how mean.
Apr 29th, 2007
bade
Hey whassup! Hilary wake up wake up on a Saturday night!
May 2nd, 2007
alexa
she is NOT horse!
Jun 4th, 2007
Kelz
Nicole Richie is preggers…Yah Joel totally dumped Hil cuz she wouldn’t sleep with him…just like all men..trash…No but seriously I think they sucked together lol….I am happy they broke up but not happy that he is with Nicole…I like her but that is just so low to hook up with Joel liek two weeks later…and people the age gap was prolly what was causing all their fights…becuase they had different outlooks when it came down to it…I duno I like them both but not together…and Hilary does NOT look like a horse…and she is not annerexic…check out nicole if you wanna see skinny coke head….whatever we will see what happens…
Jun 14th, 2007
shut up
ok, shut the fuk up, hillary is a great person, and if u had an ounce of brains in ur dumbass head, youd no that. go to hell
Jun 22nd, 2007
mmmmmm....
their like ment for each other and now joel is datin the fuckin anerix bitch nicole!!!ughhhh i totally hate that bitch shes u gly like crap!!
anerix bitch!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jun 23rd, 2007
fallenjustice
hi. did any of you people that are trashing hils or joel think that maybe they didnt break up because of the age, maybe they just said that because they had other problems they didnt want nosey mean fuckers to blow up out of proportion. they do have personal lives too, well they should. in my personal opinion hils is awsome, joel and gc are awsome and i hate reading all this crap abusing them when NONE of us even fucking know them so just lay the fuck off. seriousely i dont like nicole ritchie. but im not gonna sit here trashing her like u guys r trashing them. its up to THEM its none of our fucking business.
thank you
sez xo
Jun 25th, 2007
amanda
im a fan of both hil and joel what ever reson they broke up is there business not everbody elses there people just like you and me .they have problems like normaly people,there both good singers and song writters t people need to stop believeing everthing that they see or hear cause lot of it is not true, hil is not a horse she is changing like everyone dose so she is stil a good role modle for young and older people same with joel so people lay of the crap i/m with you on this fallenjustice!!!
Jun 27th, 2007
Michelle
Not a fan of either of the 3, probably nicole the least because she seems to have everything and not appreciate a thing. Thought Joel and Hillary would make it, and although age does sometimes make a difference theirs wasn’t that consequential, so the break up could be something else. Well good luck to hillary. I hope she moves on and makes the best of the situation. She’s young and has more possibiliities that the other two I think. I hope you don’t change for anyone though, you are great just as you are. Can’t please anyone so just do what makes you happy.
Jul 5th, 2007
brianna
haha and now nicole richie is pregnant with joel madden’s baby. that’s what you get you fucking skank. (nicole)
hilary did nothing but everybody is blaming her. whatever.
Jul 6th, 2007
brianna
it’s true, hilary even SAID she was waiting for marriage to have sex. and obviously he wasn’t because he screwed nicole and now she’s pregnant.
but who are we to judge any of them?
Jul 6th, 2007
chelsey
everyone needs to get over the break up between those two. it is not just one person’s fault. it takes two to tango. the reaon why they broke up is between them and not the rest of the world. hilary is a terrific person and so is joel. nicole is stupider than a dog and much more but if that is who joel wants to be with then let him.hilary did not change herself for joel so whoever keeps saying that needs to learn to keeep their mouth shut. they were cute together but they weren’t soul mates. the world goes on rather they’re together or not. like i said they r both beautiful people and someday they will find the love of their life.
Jul 20th, 2007
monkie's uncle
so, is joel sad bout that he’s having a kid w/ nicole?! do you think hil feels sorry fo him too?! or does nicole stick around w/ joel just fo the baby and publicity?! ANYONE?? tks…
Aug 11th, 2007
UnbelievablePeople
People who said bad things about other people… just showed how jealous they were!!! I’m sure they all look ugly inside out. Probably they are all look like baboons! See how that it feels!
I just can’t believe how can you people are so disrespectful of other especially to someone who didn’t even do anything bad to you… people like are so sickening. You should never get any respect. People like you make me sick.
God created people to like him not like animals see how it feels to be compared to an animal. Well I guess if you act like one you will be like one!
Jun 26th, 2008
Reply to “Hilary Duff and Joel Madden Break Up”